Showing posts with label Children's books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Children's books. Show all posts

Monday, May 11, 2015

Scorpion Mountain (Brotherband Chronicles #5)

My Rating: 4/10
Goodreads: 4.44

I was tempted to just throw this one in with my review for the Slaves of Socorro, as it has many of the same problems. However, there was a little more emotional depth in this one as it shows Hal having to face the possible loss of a couple of his crew members and how he deals with it. I was a little more impressed with that. The ending, though, was rather anti-climatic and confusing. It was mostly just way too easy. Their enemies, a fanatic assassin cult, were set up to be incredibly fearsome, but they were overcome incredibly easily to the point that I kept expecting them to pop up out of nowhere at the end just to prove that they really were worth all the buildup. For a series that relies primarily on action to keep the story going, it was disappointing. I'm just hoping that the next book will be better.

Slaves of Socorro (Brotherband Chronicles #4)

My Rating: 5/10
Goodreads: 4.38

In this book, the Brotherband Chronicles mixes with the Ranger's Apprentice series as the Herons head off to Araluen to be their Skandian duty ship for a few months. I was excited to see Gilan get thrown in with the Herons, but I wasn't terribly impressed with the story overall. There was plenty of action but not a ton of character development or emotional depth. Instead of being a real continuation of the Heron's story it was more like just another humdrum adventure. I'm worried that this series, like it's companion series, is going to be stretched on indefinitely without much character development occurring over the many books.

The Royal Ranger (Ranger's Apprentice #12)

My Rating: 5/10
Goodreads: 4.41

I was surprised to hear about this one as I thought the series was over. It is an interesting addition to the series however, since Will finally gets his own apprentice and you get to see him put in Halt's position. It bothered me, though,  that throughout the book Will seems to go back and forth between acting like a copy of Halt and acting like his younger self. I would have preferred to see him acting just like an older version of his younger self. I suppose it does make sense that he would act like Halt with his apprentice since that's how he was trained, but you'd think in the thirty-or-so years in between this book and the first one he would have become a little more original. On the plus side, I did enjoy the addition of Maddie. She did help the book seem like more than just a rerun of the first book by having her own distinct personality and challenges. Other than that, the book was fairly standard for a Ranger's Apprentice book with lots of action and a decent amount of drama. It wasn't exceptional, but I'd say it's worth reading for fans of the series.

Pathfinder (Todhunter Moon #1)

My Rating: 8/10
Goodreads: 4.2

As a long-time Septimus Heap fan, I was very excited to see how Angie Sage was going to add on to the Septimus Heap world with this new series. I thought that she did an excellent job of introducing new characters and new elements of the world while still including and continuing to develop old characters. I don't know that I would recommend it for people who haven't read the Septimus Heap series because there's so many references to it that they'd probably be confused, but for Septimus Heap fans I'd say it's a must-read.

Neil Flambe and the Bard's Banquet (The Neil Flambe Capers #5)

My Rating: 6/10
Goodreads: 4.0

This book is a good addition to a zany middle-grade mystery series. Like the other books it has lots of fun history references, random plot twists, and interesting characters. I really like how the recurring characters are continually being developed throughout the series. This book focuses a lot on Neil's development and his becoming more mature and more aware of his own shortcomings. I also like this book a bit better than the last couple books in the series because it was more focused on the mystery and less on the drama between characters. There was still a good bit of drama, but not nearly as much. The main thing I have to complain about this book was the ending, which contained a rather depressing cliffhanger. I'm sure it'll be swiftly taken care of in the next book, but it was a rather abrupt end to an otherwise good book.